Tuesday, November 10, 2026

Square Peg in a Round Hole

One of those things about owning an old house: Things break. I'm on my third water heater, but that's a fairly straightforward replacement. Most recently, it was the bathroom vent fan.

I really like the style of the vent, it's an art deco design, with two lights on either side of a center strip of louvers, probably from the 50's. It's Homart brand, which has a lot of different fixtures from that era, and was one of the brands that Sears sold back then. It started out chrome metal and frosted lights, but back when I black and white painted the bathroom, I painted the main body of the fixture gloss black. The outside was in pretty good condition, but the louvers had all the chrome rusted off. I left the center nut chrome.

The light was still working, but the vent fan just stopped. I had a few theories on what might have happened. Since the rewiring of the house was done by a bunch of incompetent shysters, my first thought was that something had come undone. Second, I'd replaced the wall switch with a knob timer a few years ago, since most everyone in the house would leave it running. The switch box was very crowded, and I thought it may have come undone in there. Third, the motor may have finally given up the ghost. It's been quite noisy for a long time, like the bushings might be failing.

I was dreading having to climb up in the attic to check the wiring. The first thing I did was to pull off the cover to check it out. I've had it apart several times, usually to replace a light bulb, and usually I'll give it a little cleaning while I've got it apart. Other times I'll pull the cover off because the louvers will start getting covered with lint fuzz. I'd never looked that close at how it's wired before, but turns out it has a very clever set up!!! It's got the lights and fan motor attached to a bar held in with two screws, and each has a standard plug and socket. I plugged in a different fan (with a long cord) and verified that there was no issue with the wiring.

Indeed, when I got it all cleaned off a little better, it didn't even seem like the motor bushings were that bad. Tried plugging the motor into a different socket, and unsurprisingly it still didn't work. Did a bit of looking around, and no one has that model of motor in stock. It's got a fairly long shaft, and apparently runs at a lower RPM than most modern motors. I found a place fairly nearby that rewinds and repairs motors, and took it there. The guy there verified what I already figured out, it's bad, you can't find replacements. Said they could rewind it... for $120. Also what I figured.

I checked to see what I could find as a replacement, or could adapt to my rig. I was thinking I might just construct a box or ducting above the vent in the attic, but I found a couple of replacement fans at Home Depot for only about $25. The one that I would have liked to use was supposed to move 70 CFM. I headed over, and found a box that had been opened to measure the fan. Too big, by about 3/8”. I checked the next size down, which doesn't list the CFM, and the size looks like it will fit nicely.

Of course, it's on a big sheet metal square, far too large to fit. I took a pair of tin snips to the perimeter, and rounded the corners. Looks like it's going to fit... but when I try and get it to go in, it doesn't sit flush, because of the radius around the fan area. Bent it 90°, then around a half inch farther bent it 90° the other direction, and it worked!!! The screws into the housing were 10-24's, and I happened to have a few 10-24 stainless truss head screws.

The mounting for the lights had been integral to the old motor mount, so I was going to need to either hack up the old one to make it fit, or come up with something new. Also was going to need to come up with a way to have the stud to hold the cover on. The new fan motor has 4 threaded holes, and I figured I could mount a bar to them, and mount the original stud bracket to it, and the light sockets to the outside. The light sockets needed to be offset, so I made a couple of aluminum bars to mount them to, which would in turn mount to the cross bar. I had bought a pair of new light bulb sockets, too.

The original had a couple of angles for either light bulb, probably as something of a heat shield, and to duct the air from the louvers. I bought a 10-foot length of flashing to fashion into these. I'd previously hauled 8-foot lengths in Kutcher and thought I could go a bit longer, but I brought along the tin snips since I didn't think it'd be able to haul a full 10-foot length. It wasn't able, but it was very close!!! I had to trim off about 6”, and it fit fine. Another edition of will it fit!!!

I'd run the cross bar long, with the thought that I'd have to bend it to put the sockets into the correct position (also the reason I used steel for the cross bar). When I started measuring the fit, it came out that where I needed to put the sockets was pretty close to where the fan base sheet metal was!!! Instead of bending the steel cross bar, I just took the aluminum socket mounts, and bolted them to the fan base sheet metal, with the flashing angles sandwiched between. I made a new cross bar, just big enough to mount the original stud bracket, and mounted it with a couple of spacers to put it where it needed to be.

The replacement fan had come with a plug already installed, and I found an old plug and wire in the basement to wire the lights. It all came together nicely.

The new fan doesn't seem to move as much air as the old one, but it's much quieter!!!

No comments:

Post a Comment